This film was made in 1957 and is an indictment of Nehruvian era's large-scale industrialization. I saw it the week of 15th August 2007 in Dahod district, in the SEZ-EPZ-global outsourcing era, which was like going back to the future, and thinking about democracy, choices, modernity and spirituality.
Everything about the film is surprising, from its songs to a lucid, elegant way of setting up the conflict between labor and capital, and its beginning with Gandhi's quote that a society in which human labor is valued is like a tree with deep roots that grows strong. In hindsight, it presents the chasm between Nehru and Gandhi's visions of progress and the purpose of human life. The film is about mechanization, the rise of capital, loss of livelihoods, and the ultimate triumph of labor not just through intelligence and strength, but with reason and dignity.
The film's beauty is its humor, love between men, between man and woman, and between landlords and laborers. My favorite song is the first song of the film (and the least known), a short conversation between Dilip Kumar and Jeevan which foretells the film's story
surprisingly (just the first minute of the clip), an unsurpassed scene of bonding between friends in a film created with a feather-light, bantering touch:
(Dilip Kumar, sounding ironic):dil leke dagaa denge
yaar hain matlab ke
ye denge to kya denge
(friends- friends of convenience, (they'll) steal your heart and trick you)
(Jeevan replies):duniya ko dikha denge
yaaron ke paseene par
hum khoon baha denge
(i'll show the world- for every drop of your sweat, i'll sweat my blood)
Friend M pointed out one drawback- the female lead is the love interest of both leading men and seemingly has no choice in who she ends up with- the men decide unilaterally that "he will have her whose favorite flowers she brings as an offering to the village temple." Very nice. Here's chocolate in a wrapper. Open it. If it turns out to be white, it's yours. If it's dark, it's mine.
Despite this little flaw, the film is a great reminder for our times and worth watching many many times.